If you did not live in the sports vacuum of Philadelphia you would never understand why I would even bother writing this. If you do happen to live within the Philadelphia sports world, it makes perfect sense.
During his tenure in Philadelphia, Bobby Abreu was criticized for a lack of hustle, awful defense (despite winning a Gold Glove), and for not being clutch. The last campaign being paraded most by the villain of Philadelphia sports media, Howard Eskin. When Abreu was traded for a package of underperforming and long shot prospects, many looked to Eskin and the Phillysports media for drawing such negative attention to the player.
An excerpt from Bobby Abreu’s bullpen page
Before I get the analysis started, just one disclaimer. I am not going to infer where clutch stats
mean anything, whether they are statistically significant from stats in a
normal situation, or if some players have some clutch advantage. I am merely testing if the Philly sports
media talk was right about Bobby Abreu.
Personally, I believe any sort of “clutch” ability is a statistical
anomaly or a product of human observation bias (ex. “I watched baseball player
X hit a walk off homerun last year so he must be clutch.”
What is clutch??
What is clutch??
To start,
what exactly is clutch?????? It depends
who you ask. I will try to entertain
multiple definitions. For example, the
Elias Sports Bureau once defined it as “any at-bat in the seventh inning or
later, with the batter's team trailing by three runs or less (or four runs if
the bases were loaded). Also, I will look at a clutch situation when a runner is in scoring
position.
Dplyring the data and getting the table we need
Dplyring the data and getting the table we need
To answer the clutch questions, the answer will rely on
taking large play by play data sets and filtering them to only match the
specific criteria. I will use JimAlbert’s shortcut to make life easier on myself. I will read in data from 1998-2011,
the heart of Abreu’s career, and then filter them based on his player ID.
So for the actual method to this, its kinda messy. First, I read in the data. This involves reading in all the event files
from 1998-2011. Then I end up with a
bunch of large dataframes with many ABs we don’t care about. I then write a single function so that only
Abreu is included (note I have not named the columns and I am still using
Abreu’s retro ID. I can fix this later
but for now I will deal with it until the data is clean)
abreu <-
function(x) {
filter(x, X11 == "abreb001")
}
#I then made a career log by binding all these datasets.
#I then made a career log by binding all these datasets.
career <-
rbind(abreu1998, abreu1999, abreu2000, abreu2001, abreu2002, abreu2003,
abreu2004, abreu2005, abreu2006, abreu2007, abreu2008, abreu2009, abreu2010,
abreu2011)
The
next challenge is dealing with clutch situations, I need to filter to where the
score differential was -3:0 or -4 if the bases were loaded and it was the
seventh inning or later. I will start
with the score. The way the dataframe is
set up there is a small problem. Because
it presents the score gives “home score” and “away score”. You cannot just subtract home and away score
because sometime you would be home while other times you would be away. So I wrote a set of functions based on the
Away team ID and the team that Bobby Abreu would have been played on.
#these functions
create a variable that creates the score differential
# of the team
abreu was on.
phifunc <-
function(x) {
mutate(x, score=if_else(X2 ==
"PHI", (X9 - X10), (X10- X9)))
}
nyyfunc <-
function(x) {
mutate(x, score=if_else(X2 ==
"NYY", (X9 - X10), (X10- X9)))
}
laafunc <-
function(x){
mutate(x, score=if_else(X2 ==
"LAA", (X9 - X10), (X10- X9)))
}
Now I have a massive dataset with the score column added. Now let’s make this truly clutch and filter it for the specific conditions. To reiterate again the clutch situation is down by 3 or less in the 7th inning or later or down by 4 with the bases loaded. I wanna splice this into three different situations to compare. The non-clutch situation, the clutch situation, and the clutch and runners-in-scoring-position situation.
Now I have a massive dataset with the score column added. Now let’s make this truly clutch and filter it for the specific conditions. To reiterate again the clutch situation is down by 3 or less in the 7th inning or later or down by 4 with the bases loaded. I wanna splice this into three different situations to compare. The non-clutch situation, the clutch situation, and the clutch and runners-in-scoring-position situation.
#make a dataframe
for not clutch situations
not_clutch <-
career %>%
filter((INN_CT < 7 & BAT_EVENT_FL ==
TRUE) | ((score < -4 & BAT_EVENT_FL == TRUE) | score > 1 & INN_CT
> 6 & BAT_EVENT_FL == TRUE))
#make a dataframe for clutch situations
clutchcareer
<- career %>%
filter((score > -4 & score < 1
& INN_CT > 6 & BAT_EVENT_FL == TRUE) | (score == -4 & !is.na(BASE1_RUN_ID)
& !is.na(BASE2_RUN_ID) & !is.na(BASE3_RUN_ID) & INN_CT > 6 &
BAT_EVENT_FL == TRUE))
#lets look at
clutch plays when men were on base
clutch_risp <-
clutchcareer %>%
filter(!is.na(BASE2_RUN_ID) | !is.na(BASE3_RUN_ID))
#I then had to summarize everything into little tables and join them with the event codes table.
#I then had to summarize everything into little tables and join them with the event codes table.
#how did Abreu
perform in nonclutch situations
cnt_not_clutch
<- not_clutch %>%
group_by(EVENT_CD) %>%
count()
#join with the
event codes table
cnt_not_clutch
<- right_join(event_codes, cnt_not_clutch, by= "EVENT_CD")
cnt_not_clutch <-
select(cnt_not_clutch, EVENT_CD, event, n)
The
result ends up being this:
I then performed this for all the different situations. I then had to create another table to compare
all the situations, as well as the total.
Using the tribble function, I received this as a result:
Important to note, ‘RISP’
is a subset of ‘Clutch’ and 'Non-Clutch'. If you were to
add the rows, they would then be greater than ‘Total’.
Analysis of the
Result
PAs and ABs
PAs and ABs
·
As one would expect, most of Abreu’s at bats
during this period were non-clutch. His
AB/PA ratio was higher in clutch and risp situations because he was more
likely to get walked in those situations.
BA, OBP, SLUG, OPS
·
Interestingly, Abreu’s batting average in clutch
situations was actually higher than non-clutch and the total, and interestingly
c&r as well. However, by only .009
pts, I doubt its significant.
·
Looking at OBP, there is a clear trend in clutch
and risp situations. Too put it
simply, he was walked a lot. His OBP is
nearly .040 higher in clutch situations than non-clutch and .090 points higher
in risp situations than non-clutch.
·
His slugging percentage does not seem to be
significantly different in any situation, although slightly lower in risp.
·
As a result of a high OBP, his OPS is more than .050
points higher in clutch and risp situations than in a non-clutch
situation. It is worth to note, in all
situations Bobby Abreu’s OPS is exceptional and on par with a perennial
All-Star and Hall of Famer.
BBs
·
By far the most significant factor in the
difference between Abreu’s walk and clutch and non-clutch numbers were his
increase in walks in clutch situations.
This makes sense, in these situations pitchers were afraid of Bobby
Abreu and would father put him on base than give him something to hit. In non-clutch situations, Abreu was only
walked 14.2% of the time. In clutch
situations it went up to 18.3% and in risp situations it was 25.7% with more
than half of those walks being intentional.
Although Philly broadcasters may have thought Abreu was a bum in clutch
situations, pitchers were certainly not in agreement.
Conclusion
Although Bobby Abreu’s only significant difference in a
clutch situation as opposed to a non-clutch situation was his higher rate of walks,
this effectively disproves any notion that he was not a clutch hitter. While I believe the characteristic of being
“clutch” likely does not exist, Bobby Abreu hit just as well in clutch
situation as non-clutch and that is a pretty good statistic. I am sure any manager would be fine with a
baseball player hitting his total average in any situation when they post
numbers like .293/.405/.481.
Let us all forgive Abreu from any damning accusations from
Philly sports media and recognize him for his HOF level career.
Visualizations
Visualizations
Humans are visual creatures. Lets use some ggplots to take a look at how Abreu performed in certain events.
This of course is not readily by humans because field outs
occur at such a higher rate than any other event. The way to solve this is to scale everything
down to logarithms.
The log count of each event happening
in a non-clutch situation
The log count of each event happening
in a clutch situation.
The log count of each event happening
in a RISP situation.
Hitting Statistics Across different situations.


















